When Does a Contract Become Legally Binding?

Article summary

• A contract becomes legally binding in England and Wales only when there is a clear offer, acceptance, consideration from each party, and an intention to create legal relations. 
• If one of the elements is missing, the Court may refuse to enforce an agreement
• Contracts can be verbal if the required elements are in place
• You can protect yourself from being legally bound by a contract before you are ready by using the wording “subject to contract” in your correspondence with the other party

A contract becomes legally binding in England and Wales only when there is a clear offer, acceptance, consideration from each party, and an intention to create legal relations. The absence of one of these elements may mean that there is no legally enforceable contract. 

In business, not knowing when a contract becomes legally binding under UK law can lead to lengthy and costly disputes, lost revenue, and even the loss of commercial opportunity. For business owners, startup founders, and professionals, it is absolutely essential to understand when an agreement moves from being theoretical to enforceable under the law. Thankfully, with some knowledge of this subject, you can protect your legal position by making it clear when you are ready to enter into a contract.

In this article, we will explain the four essential elements of a legally binding contract and how to avoid complications when entering into contracts. 

What are the four key elements of a legally binding contract?

For an agreement to be enforceable in England and Wales, each of the following four key elements must be present:

1. Offer – There must be a clear expression of willingness to enter into an agreement by both parties on specific terms which is capable of acceptance.
2. Acceptance – An unequivocal agreement to those terms without variation.
3. Consideration – There must be something of value provided by each party, such as goods, services, payment, or a promise to act or refrain from acting.
4. Intention to create legal relations – Parties must intend the agreement to have legal force.

Remember, if any one of these elements is missing, there is no binding contract.

Example: A catering company supplier emails a restaurant offering to supply 500 kg of fresh vegetables every month for £5,000, delivered every Monday morning from the 1st September 2025. In response, the restaurant replies, “We agree to your offer for 500 kilos monthly at £5,000, delivery each Monday from 1^st September 2025”. In this situation, we have an offer (i.e. the email from the supplier) with specific quantity, price, and delivery terms. We have an acceptance from the restaurant. We have consideration in the form of a £5,000 payment for the vegetables. And finally, we have a clear intention; a commercial agreement to source vegetables for a restaurant from a supplier.

What does ‘intention to create legal relations’ mean?

The intention to create legal relations simply means that parties want to enter into a legal arrangement. For example, one party wishes to purchase IT services in return for an agreed fee. Without this element being in place, the courts will not enforce a contract. 

The courts will look at any evidence to show that both parties genuinely intended to form a contract. When verifying if this is in place, they will weigh up the context, including the wording and behaviour of the parties at the time. It should be clear that parties objectively intended their deal to be legally enforceable. It can sometimes be difficult to prove this is the case, however.

In the case of Blue v Ashley [2017] EWHC 1928 (Comm), Mr Jeffrey Blue, a financial advisor, claimed that during an evening of drinking in a London pub with Mike Ashley, the owner of Sports Direct, Mr Ashley verbally promised to pay him £15million if he could help get the Sports Direct share price to £8 per share. The conversation was jovial, made in the presence of others over drinks, and the share price subsequently did rise above £8. 

Mr Blue later brought a claim to enforce what he asserted was a binding oral contract. In this case, the High Court found no legally binding contract existed. The judge took the view that the informal setting involving substantial alcohol, coupled with the light-hearted tone and laughter, meant that, objectively, the conversation lacked the necessary seriousness and intention to create legal relations. In addition, the alleged offer was too vague, with no clear terms (e.g. precise timeframe).

Does a contract need to be in writing and signed?

In general, a contract does not have to be in writing or signed in order to be legally binding. Legal agreements can be in the form of an email, text message, or even in verbal conversations, as long as the essential elements are present.

If you are wary of entering into a contract too early, one way to avoid this situation is to mark any correspondence “subject to contract”. This is a well-established way to show that negotiations are ongoing and no binding agreement exists until a formal contract is signed. 

For businesses, it is particularly important to document the point at which negotiations move from exploratory to binding.

Final words

In England and Wales, a handshake deal can be binding if the key elements are present and there is an intention to create legal relations. For commercial parties, the default assumption is that agreements are intended to be enforceable, and the burden falls on them to make it clear if they are not. When in doubt, take legal advice. The cost of seeking clarity at the outset is far lower than the cost of litigating a dispute over whether a contract was ever formed. Our contract law Solicitors have the necessary expertise to assess whether these elements exist to the standard required by the courts.

FAQs

What are the four elements needed for a legally binding contract in England and Wales?
A legally binding contract requires a clear offer, acceptance of that offer without changes, consideration from each party, and an intention to create legal relations. If any of these elements is missing, the agreement may not be enforceable.

Can a verbal agreement be legally binding?
Yes. A contract does not have to be in writing to be legally binding. A verbal agreement can be enforceable if it contains all four essential elements of a contract. However, written agreements provide clearer evidence if a dispute arises.

What does ‘intention to create legal relations’ mean?
It means that both parties genuinely intend the agreement to be legally enforceable. Courts will look at the wording, context, and behaviour of the parties to decide if this intention exists. Social or informal arrangements, such as in the Blue v Ashley case, may not meet this requirement.

How can I make sure I am not bound by a contract too early?
You can include the phrase “subject to contract” in correspondence to show that no binding agreement exists until a formal document is signed. This approach is widely recognised in England and Wales.

Do courts assume that business agreements are legally binding?
Yes. In commercial situations, the default assumption is that agreements are intended to be legally enforceable. If the parties do not want to be bound, they must make this clear in writing.

To instruct one of our Contract Law Solicitors, please fill in our contact form or email us at [email protected]